Book Writing AdviceBook, Writing, Advice
ServiceScape Incorporated
ServiceScape Incorporated

How To Avoid and Repair Plot Holes in Your Story

Plot holes are inconsistencies or gaps that challenge the logic of a story, creating contradictions that can pull readers out of the narrative. They can involve lapses in the storyline, character development, or the story's worldbuilding elements. Whether it's a character knowing something they shouldn't, the unexplained disappearance of a crucial object, or a problem that could be easily solved with an existing story element, plot holes can make a story feel disjointed or incomplete.

Avoiding plot holes is crucial to maintaining the integrity and believability of a story. As writers, our goal is to immerse our readers in the world we've created. Plot holes can jolt readers out of this immersion, making them question the story's logic instead of focusing on the narrative progression. They can create confusion, cause readers to lose faith in the story or its characters, and may result in a lack of engagement or even abandonment of the book. Consequently, keeping our narratives free from plot holes enhances reader satisfaction and ensures a smoother, more coherent storytelling experience.

Understanding plot holes

Understanding the different types of plot holes is the first step towards avoiding them in your narrative; they commonly fall into the following categories:

  • Timeline inconsistencies: These occur when the timeline within the story doesn't align or add up logically. For instance, events may happen out of order, characters might age inconsistently, or the story timeline might conflict with real-world historical events in historical fiction.
  • Character inconsistencies: These types of plot holes appear when characters behave out of character without any explanation, or suddenly acquire knowledge or skills that they shouldn't logically have. For example, a character might demonstrate a skill they've never learned, or they might know something that they've never been told.
  • Inconsistencies in worldbuilding: These are particularly relevant in genres like fantasy and science fiction. These plot holes emerge when the rules of the universe you've created are inconsistent or broken, such as magical systems that change without explanation, or futuristic technology that works in one scene and not the next.
  • Logical inconsistencies: These plot holes occur when something happens that just doesn't make sense in the context of the story. It could be a problem that could be easily solved with a previously introduced element, or a conflict that's resolved in a way that's contrary to the previously established logic of the story.

Examples of plot holes in popular literature

Even highly acclaimed and popular literature is not immune to plot holes. They can sneak into the narrative and leave even the most discerning readers perplexed. Here are a few notable examples from well-known books:

  • Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban by J.K. Rowling: The use of Time-Turners introduces a significant plot hole. If it was possible to change past events using this magical object, it could have been used to prevent many unfortunate incidents throughout the series, creating a paradox that's never fully addressed.
  • The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien: The eagles that rescue Bilbo and the dwarves from the trees surrounded by wolves could have easily taken them all the way to the Lonely Mountain, negating the need for their long, perilous journey. This plot hole is never adequately explained.
  • Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen: Mr. Darcy's first marriage proposal to Elizabeth is outrageously out of character, as he insults her family while declaring his love, which contradicts his otherwise consistently respectful and composed demeanor. This abrupt shift is never fully rationalized in the context of his character development.

Impact of plot holes on the reader's experience

Plot holes can significantly disrupt a reader's experience. They can cause confusion, making the reader pause to try to figure out if they missed something or if the story is flawed. This interruption can break the reader's immersion and diminish their enjoyment of the story. More significantly, plot holes can make the narrative seem less believable, undermining the reader's trust in the author and reducing their emotional investment in the characters and the story. It is, therefore, critical for writers to strive to eliminate plot holes in their work.

Techniques for avoiding plot holes

Detailed planning and outlining

The importance of a detailed outline cannot be overstated when crafting a coherent and captivating narrative. Outlines serve as the story's backbone, offering a clear structure and sequence for the unfolding events. By visualizing the narrative arc from start to finish, writers can identify potential gaps or inconsistencies that may evolve into plot holes. A comprehensive outline also aids in tracking the rise and fall of tension and the relationships between characters, ensuring a seamless, logically progressing story that thoroughly engages the readers.

Perfecting Your Plot: How to Structure a Narrative

Planning character arcs is another pivotal aspect of storytelling. Character arcs represent the transformation or inner journey of a character throughout the story. Ensuring that these arcs are well-planned and consistent helps to avoid character inconsistencies, which are a common type of plot hole. Writers need to delve deep into each character's motivations, desires, and the challenges they encounter. This understanding informs the characters' decisions and actions, making them relatable and believable. Consequently, well-drawn character arcs contribute to a more cohesive and compelling narrative.

Lastly, key plot points need careful planning and integration into the story. These significant events, whether they're unexpected twists, conflicts, or revelations, drive the narrative forward. By planning these plot points in advance, writers can ensure their logical consistency and seamless integration into the story. Each plot point has consequences and these should align with the established rules of the story's world and the development of characters. Keeping this in mind can help writers maintain narrative consistency and avoid introducing unintended plot holes.

Consistent worldbuilding

A vital aspect of storytelling, particularly in genres like fantasy and science fiction, is effective worldbuilding. It involves creating a complete and complex environment for your story, complete with its unique rules, physical laws, cultures, social structures, and more. Keeping track of these world rules is fundamental to avoiding plot holes. For example, if magic exists in your story, it's essential to define its limitations and costs, ensuring it's not used as a convenient tool to solve unsolvable problems. Detailed notes or a "world bible" can be helpful in tracking these rules and keeping them consistent throughout your story.

Worldbuilding in fantasy and science fiction writing

Maintaining internal consistency is another significant aspect of worldbuilding. This means that once you've established the rules of your world, they need to remain consistent unless you provide a logical reason within the story for any change. Inconsistencies can confuse readers and disrupt their suspension of disbelief, creating potential plot holes. If a creature in your story can only be killed by a particular weapon in one chapter, it shouldn't be conveniently defeated by a different weapon in a later chapter without an explained reason. Thus, meticulous attention to detail and consistency is key to successful worldbuilding and plot hole prevention.

Thorough character development

Deep and thorough character development is pivotal to crafting a compelling narrative and avoiding plot holes. At the heart of this process lies understanding character motivations. Characters should have clear objectives, fears, desires, and values that drive their actions and reactions within the story. A well-defined motivation provides a logical basis for the decisions a character makes, making their actions feel believable and consistent. Without clear motivations, characters might act in ways that serve the plot but contradict their established personality or values, creating potential plot holes.

In addition to understanding motivations, keeping character responses consistent is crucial in maintaining the integrity of your narrative. Characters should react to events in a way that aligns with their personality, history, and the current circumstances in the story. If a character behaves out of character without a plausible explanation, it can create a disconnect for the reader.

Techniques for repairing plot holes

The role of editing in spotting plot holes

The art of crafting a seamless narrative involves not just the initial act of writing, but also the vital process of editing. An integral part of editing lies in self-assessment, where writers need to turn a critical eye towards their own work. Self-editing involves going back to your manuscript and methodically examining the storyline, character development, and the consistency of the world you've built. Techniques such as taking comprehensive notes, highlighting areas of concern, and reassessing character arcs and motivations can be instrumental in spotting plot inconsistencies. Another useful strategy is to change the way you read your manuscript. Reading the story out loud or even starting from the end and working your way to the beginning can provide a fresh perspective and help identify areas of the story that might not follow logically.

However, despite the thoroughness of self-editing, it's possible to overlook plot holes in your narrative due to familiarity with the content. This is where the crucial role of a fresh set of eyes comes into play. Beta readers or writing groups can offer an outside perspective on your work. Their distance from the creative process means they can spot things that may not be apparent to you as the author. These readers can provide an objective assessment of your narrative, pointing out parts of the story that may feel disjointed or illogical.

The importance of professional editing services, in particular, should not be understated. Professional editors are experts at identifying gaps or inconsistencies in a narrative. They provide a thorough review of your manuscript, using their training and experience to spot issues that might elude even the most diligent self-editors. Not only can they help identify plot holes, but they can also suggest ways to fix them and improve the overall coherence of your story. Therefore, seeking the assistance of a professional editing service is a highly effective strategy in eliminating plot holes and enhancing the quality of your narrative.

How to address and repair plot holes once found

Once a plot hole is identified, the challenge then becomes how to address and repair it effectively. Various techniques can be utilized to fill in plot holes, depending on their nature and impact on the story. For minor inconsistencies or gaps, additional details or explanations can be woven into the narrative to bridge the hole. Sometimes, a character's dialogue or internal thoughts can be used to explain an event or decision that seemed illogical initially. For larger plot holes, it might be necessary to introduce new events or characters, or even adjust the sequence of events to ensure a logical flow. Regardless of the technique used, the goal should be to maintain the continuity and coherence of the story without disrupting the reader's engagement.

At times, the presence of a plot hole might suggest that a scene or subplot is not working as intended. In these cases, a decision must be made whether to rewrite the scene or remove it entirely. Rewriting a scene to address a plot hole is often the preferable option if the scene is critical to the overall plot or character development. It involves finding a plausible alternative that serves the same purpose in the story while ensuring logical consistency. On the other hand, if the scene doesn't contribute significantly to the story or complicates the plot unnecessarily, it might be best to remove it. Making these tough decisions requires a clear understanding of the story's direction and the elements that are essential to conveying it effectively.

To illustrate these points, consider a common type of plot hole involving character behavior: suppose in your story, a character who is established as extremely cautious and wary, without any provocation or apparent reason, suddenly decides to venture into a known dangerous situation. This is a plot hole as it stands in stark contrast with the character's established behavior.

In this case, you could address this plot hole by filling in the gap in the character's motivation. You might weave in a subplot where the character discovers a compelling reason to face the danger, like rescuing a loved one, or gaining a piece of information that's crucial for their mission. This way, the character's decision becomes consistent with their established personality, preserving the reader's immersion and faith in the narrative.

Alternatively, if the scene isn't essential to the overall story, or the character's sudden bravery complicates the plot without adding much depth, it might be more beneficial to remove the scene entirely. For instance, if this dangerous situation doesn't result in significant consequences or growth for the character, and removing it doesn't impact the story's progression, deletion could be the best option. These are the kind of tough choices a writer might need to make to ensure the integrity of their narrative and prevent plot holes from detracting from the reader's experience.

Software and tool options

In the digital age, writers have a plethora of tools and software at their disposal to aid their writing process, and these can be particularly useful in preventing plot holes. Ranging from basic word processors to advanced story-planning software, these tools offer a variety of features tailored to a writer's needs. Some notable options include Scrivener, which is designed for long-form works and allows for easy scene organization and revision; Plottr, a tool specifically for plotting and outlining that features an easy-to-use visual timeline; and World Anvil, which provides comprehensive worldbuilding features for writers of fantasy and science fiction.

How these tools can help keep track of details

Such tools can play a significant role in keeping track of the myriad details in your story, thereby aiding in the prevention of plot holes. Many writing software offer features such as character profiles, where you can store information about your characters' backgrounds, motivations, and development. Tools like Scrivener also provide corkboard and outlining features, which help in tracking the progression of your plot and keeping the sequence of events clear. Worldbuilding tools like World Anvil can help manage the complex details of your story's setting and keep your world's rules consistent. By keeping all these details organized and easily accessible, these tools make it less likely that inconsistencies will slip through.

Benefits and limitations of these tools

Despite the potential benefits, it's important to remember that writing tools and software are just that - tools. They can help you organize your thoughts, keep track of details, and spot potential inconsistencies. However, they can't replace the creativity, judgment, and critical thinking that a writer brings to the table. While they can help you manage and structure your narrative, they can't make narrative decisions for you, such as whether a plot development is compelling or a character's actions are believable. Therefore, while these tools can be very useful, they should be used as a complement to, not a substitute for, the skills and instincts of the writer.


As we reach the conclusion of our exploration into plot holes, it's worth revisiting the key strategies to avoid them. To begin with, a detailed plan and outline can provide a clear roadmap for your story, helping to avoid discrepancies in timelines, character arcs, and plot developments. Next, consistent worldbuilding is essential to prevent gaps in the rules and realities of your story's universe. Thorough character development ensures characters act consistently and their motivations remain clear, minimizing the chances of creating character-related plot holes. Regularly reviewing and editing your work, both through self-editing and by seeking fresh perspectives, can help identify and fix plot holes. Finally, various writing tools and software can assist in keeping track of details and maintaining consistency.

Consistency and attention to detail are the bedrock of good writing. These attributes are crucial in maintaining the integrity of your narrative and the suspension of disbelief in your readers. They enable your audience to immerse themselves in the story, accepting the world you've created and investing in your characters. Therefore, avoiding plot holes is not just about the technical aspects of writing, but also about respecting and valuing your readers' experience.

As we wrap up, remember that while it's important to strive for a seamless narrative, it's okay if your first draft isn't perfect. Writing is a process of continuous learning and improvement, and every writer, regardless of their level of experience, can fall prey to plot holes. The key lies in patience, persistence, and a willingness to scrutinize and revise your work. So, embrace the challenge of avoiding plot holes as an opportunity to hone your skills and elevate your writing. Let the possibility of plot holes not deter you, but rather motivate you to become an even more attentive, meticulous, and remarkable storyteller.

Header image by Poprock3d.

Get in-depth guidance delivered right to your inbox.